Will FDA TV Ad Reviews Face Court Challenges?

2 Comments

free-speech2.jpgThat’s what some wags are saying about the provision in the recently enacted FDA Amendments Act. One item in the legislation allows the FDA to delay a TV ad while agency staffers conduct a review and decide whether anything must be changed, such as disclosing serious risks.

This language was inserted in favor tougher wording that, originally, would have given the FDA authority to block a drugmaker from advertising a med that carried serious safety concerns. But that was removed over constitutional concerns. Now, though, some lawyers tell FDALegislativeWatch that the softer provision may also have trouble passing constitutional muster. The FDA’s authority “likely will be tested at some point in the courts,” David Ogden of WilmerHale tells the newsletter (subscription required).

He contends that delay airing an ad for 45 days to allow a pre-broadcast review appears to be “classic prior restraint” of speech, and pointed to the commercial speech doctrine as the basis for a court challenge. This legal theory maintains that government restrictions on commercial speech must serve a substantial government interest, be no more restrictive than needed, and are invalid if there is a clear alternative that is less intrusive, the newsletter notes. Such a battle will likely be more interesting to watch than most DTC ads.

Jump to comments

Share

Comments

  1. The industry would be pretty stupid to challenge this provision. First, they are PAYING the FDA to review the ads and SECOND they get a free pass if the ads are pre-approved and comply with FDA suggestions for changes, if any. That is, FDA cannot pull the ad after the barn door is closed. Sweet!

    We all have to sacrifice some constitutional rights for security. Why should the drug industry be exempt?

  2. My company already asks the FDA to review our ads.

Subscribe

RSS Feed

Comments feed for this post only.

Tags

Clear

Clear

All rights reserved, Nojasa LLC. Copyright, Nojasa LLC.

Thanks for trying out the new Pharmalot printing tools. If you're got any suggestions for how we can help you print better, please let us know by clicking on the contact link at http://www.pharmalot.com/