Forget Drugs, Docs Like Those Placebos: Study
3 CommentsBy Ed Silverman // January 11th, 2008 // 8:15 am
Doctors prescribe placebos more often than patients might imagine. A survey of Chicago-area physicians found that 45 per cent report they have given a patient a placebo at least once, according to a study published in this month’s Journal of General Internal Medicine, The Globe and Mail reports.
Past surveys of Israeli and Danish doctors revealed that 60 per cent and 85 per cent, respectively, admit they’ve relied on the “placebo effect” to heal patients. But should patients worry about their doctors shamming them? Though prescribing dummy pills is viewed as ethically shady, the placebo effect can work, the paper writes. Brain-scan research indicates that placebos trigger pain-relieving endorphins in the brain.
Doctors turn to placebos for a variety of reasons, according to the Chicago study, including to calm the patient, as a last resort when nothing else works, or simply to get a patient to stop complaining.
They are not necessarily handing out sugar pills disguised as real drugs, says lead researcher Rachel Sherman, a fourth-year medical student at the University of Chicago. A more common scenario is a physician who tells a patient to take ibuprofen for pain when nothing else has worked because “it might help, and it won’t hurt.” Even if the doctor doesn’t believe the drug will alleviate the physical symptoms, the placebo effect may make the patient feel better nonetheless.
Sherman - whose medical education, to this point, has included no mention of placebo use in clinical practice - says her survey of 231 physicians points to the need for more open discussion. “Perhaps this is something that will become more widely acknowledged,” she says.
Hank
Great stuff. There have been many excellent analyses of the “placebo” effect having to do with the relationship between doctor and patient, a shared definition of a problem, and a plan - all of which inspires hope (as Jerry Groopman defines it)and which has been shown to benefit tx in all contexts. This has nothing to do with “wishful thinking.”
As far as placebo vs. no tx at all, the studies are ambiguous.
ol cranky
Hank:
There have actually been some interesting (and not ambiguous) studies of the placebo effect in pain using fMRI, and I expect more studies to be published in the future. In the pain studies they have (continue to) evaluate not only the effects post treatment but also what happens in the brain in anticipation of treatment.
When stories about placebo use hit the main stream media a couple of weeks ago, a lot of people seemed to be very angry placebos were used at all. I think they may well be warranted in cases in which pharmacological intervention isn’t clinically justified (i.e., patients with viral infections who demand antibiotics, etc.)
Hank
Agree OC. I didn’t mean _all_ studies were ambiguous, but that as a group there remain a lot of questions re: mechanism, efficacy, etc. Also agree re: ethics point.