Pfizer May Reach Deal With Nigeria Over Trovan
4 CommentsBy Ed Silverman // October 27th, 2008 // 11:44 am
Pfizer and alleged victims of a drug trial it carried out in northern Nigeria hope to reach out-of-court settlement next month, lawyers told a Kano high court Monday, according to Agence France Presse.
“We have both agreed for the matter to be adjourned…to November 27 since we are making a push for final settlement out of court,” prosecution counsel Suleiman Na-Malam said. “We have agreed that the matter be adjourned to November 27, we are optimistic we will make progress on the settlement issue and then brief the court on what we will have agreed on,” Pfizer lawyer Anthony Idigbe told the court.
The Kano state government filed criminal and civil suits against Pfizer in 2006 demanding $2.75 billion in compensation for an allegedly illegal trial of its Trovan meningitis drug, which was administered to about 200 children during a triple epidemic of measles, cholera and meningitis in 1996 that claimed 30,000 lives. The trials allegedly caused the death of 11 children - five on Trovan and six in a control groupand - and led to deformity in 181, including paralysis, deafness, blindness and brain damage.
For its part, Pfizer has denied any wrongdoing, arguing the trial was conducted with the full knowledge and approval of the Kano state government. The Nigerian federal government later filed a separate suit against Pfizer before a high court in the administrative capital Abuja seeking $7 billion in damages.
In June in Dubai, Kano and the federal government jointly told Pfizer they would settle for a total of $ 650 million. Pfizer offered to pay them about $10 million dollars, but the offer was rejected, according to a source close to the negotiations.
xfin31
“Pfizer offered to pay them about $10 dollars, but the offer was rejected, according to a source close to the negotiations.”
heh, no surprise there, then. $10 doesn’t buy a lot, even in Nigeria!
Ed Silverman
Hi Xfin31,
That should have been $10 million, and the typo is now fixed. Hopefully, that was an obvious sort of a typo, as typo’s go.
Regards
ed
Tanin
Hi Ed,
I might be mistaken but wasn’t there only 200 people in the trial. As this was a controlled trial I am guessing probably only about 100 kids recieved Trovan, therefore your adverse event numbers seem a tad high
Cheers,
Ed Silverman
Hi Tanin,
You raise a good point, and it appears the AFP report combined numbers from the two arms of the trial - about 100 kids given Trovan and another 100 or so kids given a different antibiotic. I will find a way to clarify that.
Regards
ed