Doc Goes To Jail In Pfizer Research Fraud Case
18 CommentsBy Ed Silverman // June 25th, 2010 // 7:45 am
Scott Reuben, who was accused of faking research for a dozen years in published studies that suggested after-surgery benefits from Vioxx and Celebrex, was sentenced to six months in jail plus three years supervised release after he pleaded guilty earlier this year to health care fraud, MassLive reports. The 51-year-old must also repay $361,932 in research grants, forfeit assets worth at least $50,000 and pay a $5,000 fine.
The former chief of acute pain at Baystate Medical Center received grants from various drugmakers but never performed the studies, fabricated patient data and submitted info to anesthesiology journals that was unwittingly published. Later, an investigation found 21 papers published in journals between 1996 and 2008 in which Reuben made up some or all of the data (background here and here).
The hospital asked the journals to retract the studies, some of which reported favorable results from painkillers including Pfizer’s Bextra, Celebrex and Lyrica, and Merck’s Vioxx. His studies also claimed Wyeth’s Effexor antidepressant could be used as a painkiller. Pfizer gave Reuben five research grants between 2002 and 2007, and he was a member of the company’s speakers bureau, giving talks about Pfizer drugs to colleagues. Separately, the journal Anesthesia & Analgesia retracted 10 of Reuben’s studies last year while the journal Anesthesiology retracted three studies.
pharmavet
Who’s going to host the Jeff Foxworthy show?
Stephany
I hope this sets a precedent!!
or
Who’s going to replace Lee Majors as The Fall Guy?
MsPiggy
Interesting that Scott Reuben commits felony fraud while gets sentenced to six months jail time (which in real terms mean probably around three months at some country club facility and then home detention). Then he will have to repay some grant money, has his privileges with the hospital terminated, but no where do you read about his medical license being revoked and suspended.
If this is the case, he could be moving down to UM Florida in the near future applying for a job and government grants as a celebrated colleague of Nemeroff in all practical theory.
Justice?
Evelyn Pringle
Real justice. A 6 month jail term for this level of fraud. A pothead can get more than that for buying or selling a joint. And we wonder why the fraud never ends in the field of medicine?
Stephany
Evelyn Pringle and Ms.Piggy right on target with the comments on this one!
Anne PME
What about his medical license?
Anne PME
Maybe he will find a profitable second career at an HMO or PBM in comparative effectiveness research!?!
Matthew Holford
“…an investigation found 21 papers published in journals between 1996 and 2008 in which Reuben made up some or all of the data…
Plus ca change, plus ca la meme chose… Thanks be to God that all the other studies that get published are scrupulous in their presentation of the truth.
Matt
Tim
This is one of the reasons Massachusetts passed laws banning onerous drug marketing in the state. Notice that the drug companies(Pfizer,Wyeth) never picked up on this scam, they were too busy celebrated the ‘results”, paying Reuben big bucks.It was his own hospital that found out the research was a joke. These companies have only one interest and it is not patients!!
Justice in MI
Interesting to Pfizer was pushing the same indication for Bextra–perioperative pain–which was part of the big bust.
From what I understand, there was no real data in that instance either.
Batman
This guy takes the cake. Total scum conduct. Lets not forget the people that were given unproven drugs for pain that really should have been out of pain on the other medicines. He let people suffer for profit.
His med license should be yanked permanently.
MsPiggy
This only gets better or worse depending on how you look at it?
Here –>http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5gH2GqHuDPSq2sPKULEYKUR-DceSwD9GI9JMG0
His lawyers claim Scott Reuben is suffering from Bipolar. You have to wonder when this diagnosis came about?
Was it before or after he was caught with his hands in the cookie jar. It might serve justice well to place this fella on a forced outpatient court order for medication compliance.
Any suggestions on what combo/cocktail of drugs will keep his chemical imbalance/behavioral disorder in check?
survivor030406
@ Matthew Hobbard
NEMJ- New England Journal of Medicine, just did their own investigation of their so-called “prestigious” medical journal. They discovered that 89% of the so-called studies they published were a bunch of made-up phony baloney!
WAKE UP! TRUST NOTHING!
Pilly
Ms Piggy,
I would suggest to start anyone with similar tendencies on cipramil high dose. Then when they go psychotic after lack of sleep an antipsychotic such as Olanzapine. Then some stibesterol to control the weight gain and increased appetite, although that’s for food not money now. Oh and I forgot the lithium for the bipolar and of course the carbamazapins to augment it. These days carbamazapine is used to stabilise people something to do with the electricity in the brain. Which brings me to my penultimate suggestion, if the sleeping pills don’t work - ECT. Then a lobotomy if that doesn’t work. Did I say Venlafaxine because he may be depressed? How’s that?
pharmavet
I understand that as a result of the decision the Blue Collar Comedy Tour is going on hiatus. Maybe we can get Larry the Cable Guy and Ron White to split time with Jeff in the Graybar Hotel.
gerson jacobs
I would like to hear from the hospital’s IRB. What is their excuse?
Excon
Psychotropic drugs are as big (if not bigger) a joke than the supplement industry. They typically just decrease a persons quality of life. They should be more stringently monitored than narcotics. Many of these poor souls could probably have better live by eating properly, exercising, and working through their problems with therapy. Their are just WAY too many presumptive diagnoses going on here. First course of action in most cases “should” be a sugar pill.